Tuesday, 12 January 2016

On the Issue of Ministerial Salary in Singapore

Many have thought it outrageous that Singaporean ministers are one of the best-paid ministers in the world. But are the salaries really too high? Do our ministers expect too much? Or can these salaries be justified?

I have given this issue some recent thought and hope to share my findings.

The pragmatic argument

Many who claim that ministerial salaries are too high often say that such expenditure is wasteful - that the money we use to pay our MPs could be better spent on other things. Sounds reasonable at first. Still, is this the right way to think about things? Does paying the supposedly high ministerial salary really restrict us from other sorts of expenditure? Or is this argument something we just accept at face value, something we use to justify our disgruntlement?

Practically speaking, ministerial salaries are but a tiny drop in a full glass when compared to the resources the Government has at its disposal. In 2015 alone, Singapore spent $68.22 billion dollars in total. Even the tens of millions of dollars spent on paying ministerial salaries are less than 1% of that staggering amount. Viewed in this light, the amounts of money we pay our ministers do not seem unreasonably high - indeed, it is a small price to pay to ensure the smooth running of our country. Even if we were to reduce this salary, there would not be any significant amount of funds freed up for other purposes. It would serve no purpose.

The problem with this line of thinking is that it assumes that our high ministerial salaries are sucking up vital funds, funds that could make an enormous difference elsewhere if our ministers weren't so selfish. In truth, this is clearly not the case. Moreover, if we could solve serious problems just by throwing more money at them, I am inclined to believe that our Government - with its history of strategic foresight and long-term planning - would be willing to make the expenditure.

Given this, there really is no reason for us to quibble over the exact amounts our ministers are paid - so long as it is high enough to provide adequate compensation for their work, it is highly unlikely that a little more or less here and there will affect the amount of money available for other uses.

The ethics argument

Still, there is admittedly need to decide on a notion of "fair" pay. The past practice has been to peg ministerial pay to the private sector. Whatever the other flaws of this method, it ensures that no potential minister is prevented from taking up the job because of uncompetitive salaries.

One familiar rebuttal to this is that ministers should not serve out of a desire for money, but out of an innate desire to serve the people. A high salary, it is said, will only foster greed and inculcate the wrong motivations for taking up the job.

Indeed, in an ideal world, we would find a ready supply of suitably qualified people willing to take on the various burdens of public service (some of which include dealing with Singaporeans' never-ending list of collective complaints) for significantly lower pay than they could otherwise earn, all out of the goodness of their own hearts. Such a scenario would be best, if it could be attained.

The reality, however, is that Singapore already has a limited pool of talented people to tap on, and within these few people, even fewer have a desire to serve that is so strong it can overcome the burdens of the job. (Contrary to popular belief, being a good politician is quite a thankless task.) Can we really afford to turn these people away just because they aren't as perfect or selfless as we would like them to be? Who among us would be willing to do such a job - having to debate complex issues of policy, win the people's support, all while dealing with the never-ending ire of the general public? In the end, ministers are people, like us. Can we really expect to hold them to standards we would not expect ourselves to meet?

For me, at least, the answer is no. I will not hold my ministers to higher standards than I would impose upon myself, because I accept that they too are people, who will have their fair share of human failings. And, that means, if they are called upon to perform a task nobody else is willing or able to do, they should be duly compensated for it.

The root cause

We have, by now, established that ministerial salaries are not unjustifiably high. Or at least, that the matter is not so clear cut as some would believe.

Why, then, do we maintain such anger at our minister's wages?

In short, because we are jealous. We feel it's unfair for ministers to command such salaries when the trains break down every other week, when housing prices remain high, when COE prices go up, when oil prices drop but the petrol prices don't. We feel it is unfair that, while we struggle to make ends meet, struggle with the endlessly increasing cost of living and stagnant wages, our ministers are exempt from this struggle. They have it easy, earning millions per year with a cushy position and job security, all while they seem incompetent and lazy to boot. It is unfair, and we resent them for it.

In a way, this is a convenient outlet through which we can express our anger. Anger at the system, anger at it for failing us, anger at our struggles, anger at the unfairness of it all. We use this as a justification for our anger, and this anger gives us self-validation when there is no other way to obtain it. It gives us something we can easily blame for our troubles, so we can escape the burden of responsibility.

And yet, we must acknowledge that these feelings are largely irrational. It is easy to be angry when the train breaks down and we get delayed. It is not so easy to accept that this is the result of mistakes long past, the result of lax immigration policies that led to overcrowding, mistakes long past that we can no longer change. Not so easy to accept that these selfsame ministers have since recognised their error and begun fixing it, that there has been improvement in the situation, that such a problem cannot be fixed in a year and a day. Easy to complain about rising prices. Not so easy to accept that inflation is natural, or that prices are subject to global supply and demand factors often beyond Singapore's control. Easy to complain about COE. Not so easy to accept that it has been largely responsible for preventing congestion. Easy to complain about stagnant wages. Not so easy to accept that, for better or worse, this is the market wage - either take the pay and work, or find another job. Easy to complain our ministers are incompetent. Not so easy to acknowledge that, whatever our complaints, the country is exceptionally well-run by most standards.

It's easy to be angry, considering how often we feel like complaining, but it doesn't do anybody any favours, least of all not ourselves. Not if we stubbornly refuse to help ourselves and take charge of our own lives.

Final thoughts

Perhaps ministerial salaries are high - I don't claim to know exactly how much their work is worth, and while I think it's not unreasonably high, certainly the reader is free to disagree.

Regardless, I think that we should reflect on why we object to our MPs being paid such high salaries. Is it for sound, logical reasons? Or is it merely because we want to complain about something?

To me, at least, that question must be answered, before we can reach anything like consensus on this issue.